Definitions

  • I choose this term to describe the repeated and negative thinking about one’s financial situation (either of past or future), as suggested by @debruijn2020
  • If it’s focused from present to the past, it’s called financial rumination:
    • Repetitive, passive, and pessimistic thinking about the possible causes and consequences of one’s financial concerns (@debruijn2020, @simonse2024)
    • Tendency towards repetitive and persistent thoughts about money (@johar2015)
    • Preoccupations with financial scarcity, like intrusive thoughts about pressing financial needs (@vandijk2022)
  • If it’s focused from present to the future, it’s called financial worry:
    • Repeated and negative thinking about the uncertainty of one’s future financial situation (@debruijn2020)
    • The negative psychological consequences of insufficient resources to deal with a real or perceived threat to one’s standard of living/finances, as a subdomain of financial distress (@rosso2024)
    • Being upset for going through financial strain due to losing physical and economic ability, and lack of independence (@sharif2020)
  • To @marjanovic2013, financial preoccupation defined as this is part of a bigger construct called Financial threat

Theoretical frameworks


How it’s measured

  • @debruijn2020 used the FWR scale to measure both financial worry and rumination
  • @johar2015 adapted questions from a rumination response scale:
    • ‘I can’t stop thinking about my finances’
    • ‘Memories about my finances have limited my enjoyment of life’
    • ‘I have a hard time getting thoughts of my finances out of my head’
    • ‘I try to figure out the reasons for my financial situation’
    • ‘My finances are never far from my head’
    • ‘I find myself replaying events related to my finances over and over in my mind’
    • ‘I often get distracted from what I’m doing by thoughts about finances’
    • ‘I seldomly have difficulty concentrating on a current task due to finances’
    • ‘I rarely become ‘lost in thought’ about my finances’
    • ‘When I think about my finances, it makes me feel sad’
    • ‘I become angry when I think about my finances’
    • ‘I rarely get upset with myself about my finances’

Determinants

Past changes in financial situation

  • @debruijn2020:
    • Improvements in the past situation of one’s household decreased financial worry-rumination indirectly (β=-0.13) through making ends meet (β=-0.11)

Income

  • @debruijn2020:
    • Increased log(income) was related with increased financial worry-rumination indirectly (β=—0.23) through:
      • Making ends meet (β=-0.16)
      • Financial buffer (β=-0.04)
      • Current debts (β=-0.02)
  • @johar2015: income <40k USD led to increased rumination levels (OR=1.58)

Gender

  • @weissman2020 found being female increases likelihood of getting worried about:
    • Paying for bills (OR=1.4), serious medical cost (OR=1.3), expected medical cost (OR=1.2), retirement (OR=1.2), children’s college (OR=1.2)
    • Maintaining standard of living (OR=1.2)

Age

  • @debruijn2020 found a direct relationship between older age and decreased financial worry-rumination:
    • 35-64 (β=-0.10, vs. <34y)
    • 65-80 (β=-0.12, vs. <34y)
  • @weissman2020 suggested 45-64y age group (vs. 18-44y) had decreased worry episodes about:
    • Paying for bills (OR=0.79), serious medical cost (OR=0.90), and children’s college (OR=0.59)

Ethnicity

  • @weissman2020 found skin color predicted worriedness:
    • Hispanic (vs. non-Hispanic White): paying for bills (OR=2.1), serious medical cost (OR=1.6), expected medical cost (OR=1.9), retirement (OR=1.4), children’s college (OR=1.5), and maintaining standard of living (OR=1.5)
    • Non-Hispanic Black (vs. non-Hispanic White): paying for bills (OR=1.5), and expected medical cost (OR=1.1)

Education

  • @weissman2020 found education level was associated with different types of worry:
    • Less than high-school (vs. undergraduate): paying for bills (OR=1.5), serious medical cost (OR=1.2), expected medical cost (OR=1.5), and maintaining standard of living (OR=1.2)
    • High-school (vs. undergraduate): paying for bills (OR=1.1), and expected medical cost (OR=1.1)
    • Degree/above (vs. undergraduate): paying for bills (OR=0.50), serious medical cost (OR=0.66), expected medical cost (OR=0.54), retirement (OR=0.69), children’s college (OR=0.77), and maintaining standard of living (OR=0.70)

Mental health

  • @weissman2020 reported serious psychological distress lead to increased worrying about:
    • Paying for bills (OR=6.7), serious medical cost (OR=2.2), expected medical cost (OR=3.0), retirement (OR=2.9), children’s college (OR=3.3)
    • Maintaining standard of living (OR=4.8)

Physical health

  • @weissman2020 suggested number of chronic health conditions predicted financial worry:
    • One condition (vs. zero): paying for bills (OR=1.3), and maintaining standard of living (OR=1.2)
    • Two or more (vs. zero): paying for bills (OR=2.1), serious medical cost (OR=1.3), expected medical cost (OR=1.9), retirement (OR=1.4), children’s college (OR=1.5), and maintaining standard of living (OR=1.7)

Outcomes

Self-control

  • @johar2015 showed that:
    • High levels of rumination was associated with increased smaller-sooner choosing behavior (OR=6.35)
    • This relationship was moderated (OR=1.46) by frame (gain vs. loss), controlling by income

Mental health

  • @ryu2023 suggest increased financial worries are associated with psychological distress (β=0.25), moderated by:
    • Marital status: being married or cohabiting nerfs the negative relationship (β=-0.06)
    • Employment status (vs. unemployed): being employed (β=-0.09) and retired (β=-0.09) buffs mental health
    • Household income (vs. 100k USD): income is inversely proportional to stress; 0—34k (β=0.10) and 35—74K (β=0.06)
    • Tenure (vs. renters or others): being a homeowner nerfs negative outcomes (β=-0.06)